The Best Home Warranty Providers of 2023

Avoid Costly Home Repairs & Appliance Breakdowns

List updated October 2025
56,690 Real Customer Reviews
Read Our Advertising Disclosure for More Details.

Home Warranty Companies in Ohio

List updated October 2025
1
Best Budget Friendly Option
A+ Service Provider
9.6

Better Penny score

Choice Home Warranty
Get $75 OFF + 1 Month FREE
  • 20,000+ 5 Star Reviews
  • Over 1.9 Million Homes Covered
  • Largest Network of Technicians
  • 24/7 Customer Service
VIEW PLANS
52697 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.0 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 52697 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

52697 Reviews
Trustpilot
2
9.4

Better Penny score

ARWHome
$200 OFF Limited Time
  • Nationwide coverage
  • Partnered with the most recognized insurance companies in the world.
  • No age limitations on appliances and systems.
  • Monthly payments without long-term commitments.
VIEW PLANS
1052 Reviews
Trustpilot
3.2 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 1052 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

1052 Reviews
Trustpilot
3
9.0

Better Penny score

Home Warranty of America
$150 OFF + 1 MONTH FREE
  • Trusted For Over 25 Years
  • 24/7 Customer Service
  • 25,000+ Contractors Nationwide
  • 30 Day Money Back Guarantee
VIEW PLANS
2588 Reviews
Trustpilot
3.9 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 2588 User Reviews

Good
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Great
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

2588 Reviews
Trustpilot
4
8.6

Better Penny score

Home Service Club
$75 OFF + 1 MONTH FREE
  • 24/7 Customer Support
  • No Age Limit On Covered Items
  • No Inspection Required
  • 25,000+ Contractors Nationwide
VIEW PLANS
1 Reviews
Trustpilot
3.2 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 1 User Reviews

Good
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Great
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

1 Reviews
Trustpilot
5
8.5

Better Penny score

First Premiere Home Warranty
$250 OFF + 2 Months & FREE
  • 2023 Best In Service Award
  • Fastest Claims Dispatch
  • Highest Renewal Rates
  • Senior & Veteran Discounts
VIEW PLANS
352 Reviews
Trustpilot
1.9 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 352 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

352 Reviews
Trustpilot

BetterPenny.com Score:

Our Ranking consists of the following 3 scoring criteria:

  • Total Score

    Total Score is a numerical estimate of the brand's overall quality based on reviews by anybody seeking to share a review. The brand's review score will be included in the our Total Score. If a company does not have a review rating, the total score will be determined solely by Consumer Interest.

  • Consumer Interest

    Consumer Interest is a simple calculation to determine how visitors engage with the brands on our website. User interest is based on clicks and transactions received in the last 7 days. This interest may vary based on an updated weekly average.

  • Products & Services

    Our editorial staff researches and reviews financial services based on criteria such as product and service range, ease-of-use, online accessibility, customer support, special accolades, and more. Each brand is assigned a score for each criterion based on the offerings in that category. If our staff is unable to discover information relevant to a brand's Products & Services Score, it will not be calculated.

Consumer Reviews

Choice Home Warranty
Read review
American Residential (ARWhome)
Read review
Home Warranty of America
Read review
First Premier Home Warranty
Read review

Recent Reviews

Excellent technician and prompt.

This agent has a special talent to deal with customers

Very quick and easy process

It was a pleasure speaking with Nove because of his sensitivity of the nature of a previous declined payment. He is very curious and willingness to help me rectify the issue.

I delt with other home insurance companies and have always had to fight to get items fixed. This was the first claim have field with Home Warranty of America and i had a contractor out with in 36 hours, they found the issue and fixed the problem that same visit. I was very impressed and had no issues and did not have to fight to get my refrigerator fixed.

Our #1 Consumer Choice
A+ Service Provider
9.6

Better Penny score

Choice Home Warranty
Get $75 OFF + 1 Month FREE
  • 20,000+ 5 Star Reviews
  • Over 1.9 Million Homes Covered
  • Largest Network of Technicians
  • 24/7 Customer Service
4.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 52697 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

Understanding Home Warranty Protection

Owning a home is a significant investment, and with that investment comes the responsibility of maintaining the various systems and appliances within the property. While regular maintenance can help extend the lifespan of these essential components, unexpected breakdowns are still a possibility. This is where a home warranty comes into play, offering homeowners a layer of protection and peace of mind against unexpected repair and replacement costs.

What is a Home Warranty?

A home warranty is a service contract that covers the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances due to normal wear and tear. Unlike homeowner's insurance, which primarily protects against perils like fire, theft, and natural disasters, a home warranty is designed to address the everyday wear and tear that occurs with regular use of home systems and appliances.



How Does a Home Warranty Work?

When a homeowner purchases a home warranty, they are essentially entering into an agreement with a warranty provider. The provider may be an independent company specializing in home warranties or a company affiliated with a real estate transaction. The contract typically lasts for a specified period, usually one year, and can be renewed annually.

During the coverage period, if a covered system or appliance breaks down or malfunctions due to normal wear and tear, the homeowner can contact the home warranty company. The company will then dispatch a qualified service technician to diagnose the problem. If the issue is covered under the warranty terms, the company will either repair the item or, if necessary, replace it.

It's important to note that home warranties usually come with a service call fee or deductible that the homeowner needs to pay each time a service request is made. The amount of the deductible can vary depending on the warranty plan and the provider.



What Does a Home Warranty Cover?

A home warranty provides coverage for various essential components of your home. It typically includes protection for major systems like heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC), as well as electrical and plumbing systems. In addition to these critical systems, a home warranty also extends coverage to important appliances found in the kitchen, such as refrigerators, ovens, stoves, dishwashers, and built-in microwaves. Laundry appliances like washers and dryers are also commonly covered. Some plans may even include the garage door opener. It's important to carefully review the terms and conditions of the home warranty contract to understand precisely what items are covered and what limitations or exclusions may apply.



The Benefits of Home Warranties

Having a home warranty offers homeowners a range of valuable benefits. One of the primary advantages is the protection it provides against unexpected repair or replacement costs. With a home warranty in place, homeowners can better manage their budgets and avoid financial strain when major home systems or appliances break down. The convenience factor is another significant benefit, as homeowners can simply contact their warranty provider whenever an issue arises and have a qualified technician promptly address the problem. 

This eliminates the need to search for reliable contractors and saves time and effort. Moreover, having a home warranty brings peace of mind, knowing that the most crucial components of the home are safeguarded, reducing stress and anxiety related to potential breakdowns. For those planning to sell their property, a home warranty can be an appealing selling point, potentially increasing the home's value and attracting more prospective buyers. Overall, a home warranty provides homeowners with a sense of security, convenience, and financial protection against unforeseen home system and appliance failures.



Advantages Of Home Warranty Protection

Owning a home is a dream come true for many, representing a significant investment and a place where cherished memories are made. However, with homeownership comes the responsibility of maintaining various systems and appliances, which can sometimes lead to unexpected repair expenses. This is where a home warranty can prove to be a wise investment. A home warranty is a service contract that covers the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances due to normal wear and tear. Let's delve into the compelling reasons why you should seriously consider getting a home warranty for your property.

1. Financial Protection Against Unexpected Expenses: Home systems and appliances are prone to wear and tear over time. When they malfunction or break down unexpectedly, the repair or replacement costs can be substantial and strain your budget. A home warranty can alleviate this financial burden by providing coverage for these repairs or replacements, saving you from potential financial stress.

2. Simplified Repairs and Service: Dealing with unexpected breakdowns can be frustrating and time-consuming. With a home warranty in place, you can streamline the repair process by simply contacting the warranty provider when an issue arises. They will arrange for a qualified service technician to come to your home and diagnose the problem, making the entire process convenient and hassle-free.

3. Peace of Mind: Homeownership comes with its share of uncertainties. The fear of unexpected breakdowns can cause anxiety and uncertainty. A home warranty can offer peace of mind, knowing that you have a safety net in place for major home systems and appliances. You can rest assured that you are prepared to handle any unforeseen events, allowing you to enjoy your home without worry.

4. Comprehensive Coverage: Home warranty plans typically cover a range of essential systems and appliances, including HVAC, electrical, plumbing, kitchen appliances, and more. This comprehensive coverage ensures that your most crucial assets are protected, and you won't have to face the financial burden of replacing or repairing them on your own.

5. Convenience and Time-Saving: When a covered item breaks down, finding a reliable technician can be a time-consuming task. A home warranty eliminates this inconvenience as the warranty provider has a network of pre-screened service professionals. They will promptly dispatch a qualified technician to handle the repair, saving you time and effort.

6. Increased Home Value: If you plan to sell your home, having a home warranty can be a valuable selling point. It can attract potential buyers who feel more confident knowing that they will be protected against major home system and appliance failures during the initial stages of homeownership.

7. Customizable Plans: Home warranty companies often offer a variety of plans to choose from, allowing you to select coverage that aligns with your specific needs and budget. You can customize your plan based on the age of your home, the condition of its systems, and the appliances you want to include.



Conclusion

A home warranty is a valuable investment that provides homeowners with essential financial protection, peace of mind, and convenience. By covering major home systems and appliances, a home warranty can save you from unexpected expenses and streamline the repair process when issues arise. As a homeowner, it's essential to carefully review different home warranty options and choose a plan that suits your needs, ensuring that your investment and comfort are safeguarded for years to come.